The Oscar-nominated film “Emilia Perez” has generated controversy within the Hispanic community.
The film was received well by critics and gained international success, with a Rotten Tomatoes critics score of 73%. However, the film has raised questions about authenticity, due to a lack of Mexican representation in the making and production of the film.
Written by French director Jacques Audiard, the film follows the story of Emilia Perez, a cartel leader who transitions to a woman, played by Karla Sophia Gascon. Mexican-American film scoring student Lia Arjona suggested that making the movie a musical was inappropriate and poor in taste for the type of story being told.
One of the main criticisms came with the character played by Selena Gomez: Jessi Del Monte. Film enthusiasts on social media have complained about poor pronunciation and control of the Spanish language used throughout the movie by the actress.
Mexican actor Eugenio Derbez chimed in on the controversy, criticizing Gomez for her lack of fluency in Spanish on the podcast “Hablando de Cine Con,” where he was the special guest.
“Selena Gomez is indefensible,” said Derbez, who in the podcast recalled watching the movie and telling people, “Wow, what is this?”
Sam Houston State University student Melissa Anda, who is of Mexican descent, had a different perspective on the movie.
“I thought it was decent,” Anda said. “I think Selena Gomez’s character is obviously an American who learned Spanish, and the criticism is just overboard. People just want to hate on her.”
Anda also highlighted the importance of having representation for Mexico on international stages. She herself is an international student dreaming of making her country proud.
“Emilia Perez” went to win the Golden Globes award for “Best Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy” and has received 13 Oscar nominations.
Experts anticipate the film will win some of its Oscar nominations, including “Best Picture” and “Best Supporting Actress,” where Zoe Saldana leads the polls as the main contender to take home the award for her role as Rita Mora Castro. The Oscars are scheduled for March 2.
